Less Evil, More Hypocritical
Friday night, on the News Hour with Jim Lehrer, in a segment on the impact of the Internet on China, the head of Google China, Kai-Fu Lee, was asked about Google‘s agreement to filter (a polite euphemism for “censor”) their search results as a precondition for Google’s presence in China. He responded with that Google had to comply with local law and it was “better to provide information than not”. – he didn’t say exactly who it was better for, but I assume he meant the company line that it was better for the people of China.
To be fair, Yahoo and Microsoft should have undergone similar questioning, in particular how Yahoo feels about handing over the identity of a blogger to the Chinese government, which subsequently imprisoned the blogger for his criticism. (Microsoft has just censored bloggers, with the same justification – compliance with local laws)
But that just points out one fallacy of Google’s justification. Continue Reading »














